New York City, New York › Wedding Cakes & Desserts › The Vintage Cake
New to LazoAtlantic Highlands
Free to inquireRankings never for saleContracts in one thread
About The Vintage Cake
Couples planning a New York City wedding will find The Vintage Cake among the Atlantic Highlands area's wedding cakes & desserts. The studio sits within easy reach of popular venues including The Water Witch Club and Sandy Hook Chapel. This profile is free to claim; verified couple reviews — never payments — determine how it ranks.
Verified reviews
No reviews yet. Only couples who book The Vintage Cake through Lazo can leave one, and it’s the only thing that moves a Lazo Score.
Frequently asked questions
Planning a wedding cake baker in New York City
How much does a wedding cake cost in New York City?
Wedding cakes in New York City usually price by the slice — commonly $4–$9 — so a 120-guest cake often lands between $500 and $1,000. Detailed sugar work and metallic finishes raise the number; many couples pair a smaller display cake with sheet cakes to serve everyone.
How does Lazo rank wedding cakes & desserts in New York City?
Rankings come from the Lazo Score — verified reviews weighted for recency — and are never sold. Vendors without verified reviews yet start at the community baseline of 65 and earn their score as verified reviews arrive.
Wedding venues near The Vintage Cake
| Venue | Distance |
|---|---|
| The Water Witch Club | 2.5 mi |
| Sandy Hook Chapel | 4.1 mi |
| NEAPOLI Event Venue Banquet | 4.4 mi |
Straight-line distance from The Vintage Cake to each venue listed on Lazo.
New York City weddings, month by month
Days typically top out between 65° and 85° in May, June, July, August, September. The driest months are January, October, November.
| Month | High | Low | Rain | Golden hour | Sunset |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | 40° | 28° | 20% | 4:11 PM | 4:53 PM |
| Feb | 42° | 30° | 21% | 4:52 PM | 5:30 PM |
| Mar | 50° | 36° | 24% | 6:26 PM | 7:02 PM |
| Apr | 62° | 46° | 22% | 6:58 PM | 7:35 PM |
| May | 71° | 55° | 24% | 7:27 PM | 8:06 PM |
| Jun | 80° | 64° | 23% | 7:47 PM | 8:29 PM |
| Jul | 85° | 70° | 22% | 7:45 PM | 8:25 PM |
| Aug | 83° | 69° | 21% | 7:16 PM | 7:53 PM |
| Sep | 76° | 62° | 21% | 6:28 PM | 7:04 PM |
| Oct | 64° | 51° | 18% | 5:38 PM | 6:15 PM |
| Nov | 54° | 42° | 19% | 3:57 PM | 4:37 PM |
| Dec | 44° | 34° | 24% | 3:45 PM | 4:29 PM |
Average highs, lows and the share of days with 0.1″ of rain or more, from NOAA’s 1991–2020 climate normals at New York Cntrl Pk Twr (1.7 mi from New York City). Golden hour begins when the sun is 6° above the horizon; both times are for the 15th of each month in New York City.
Getting to New York City
| Airport | Distance | Est. drive |
|---|---|---|
| LGA LaGuardia Airport | 6 mi | 10 min |
| TEB Teterboro Airport | 7 mi | 10 min |
| EWR Newark Liberty International Airport | 11 mi | 15 min |
| City | Distance | Est. drive |
|---|---|---|
| Philadelphia | 83 mi | 1 hr 40 min |
| Hartford-New Haven | 88 mi | 1 hr 50 min |
| Providence | 153 mi | 3 hr 10 min |
| Baltimore | 172 mi | 3 hr 30 min |
Straight-line distance from central New York City; drive times are estimates, not routes. Airports with scheduled passenger service, from OurAirports.
Details
- Based in
- 171 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA
- Where
- Atlantic Highlands · 24 miles south of central New York City
- Listed under
- Wedding Cakes & Desserts
- In New York City
- One of 372 wedding cakes & desserts we list
- Phone
- (732) 872-2253
- Website
- Visit site
From The Vintage Cake's website
“New Jersey's Wedding Cake Destination, The Vintage Cake! Where professionally trained pastry chefs make cakes that taste as good as they look!”thevintagecake.com
- Services they list
- Tastings, Cupcakes, Dessert tables, Cookies, Macarons, Gluten-free, Delivery and setup
- Prices on their site
- From $4 per slice
Read from thevintagecake.com in October 2026. Prices and services change; confirm with The Vintage Cake before you book. Is this your business? Claim the page to write your own.
Around Atlantic Highlands
- Nearest venue
- The Water Witch Club, 2.5 mi
- Venues within 10 mi
- 19 wedding venues
- Wedding Cakes & Desserts nearby
- 10 within 10
- Guest hotels
- 6 within 5 mi
- Communities served
- Red Bank, Middletown Township, Holmdel, Fair Haven
Distances are straight-line from The Vintage Cake; counts come from the businesses and venues Lazo lists around New York City.
Before you book a wedding cake baker
Couples also looked at
PLANNING YOUR WEDDING?
Create a free wedding website — type your names, watch it come alive.
Browse the templatesIs this your business?
Claim this profile free. Reply to reviews free. Receive verified leads free — forever.
Claim this profile