Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Key West
Ranked by verified reputation — never by who paid. New vendors start at the community baseline until verified reviews arrive.
Typical cost: $500-$1,000 · Read the wedding cake baker cost guide →
Lazo lists 51 wedding cakes & desserts serving Key West and the Florida Keys, from Key Largo, Islamorada to Marathon. Every ranking below comes from verified couple reviews — never from ad spend. Vendors without verified reviews yet hold the community baseline score of 65 and are ordered alphabetically until couples weigh in.
No sponsored results. This is every wedding cake baker we list in Key West, ordered by what booked couples said — nobody can pay to move up.
-
Banana CafeNEW TO LAZO
-
Bayside GourmetNEW TO LAZO
-
Better Than Sex - A Dessert RestaurantNEW TO LAZO
-
C&C wood fire eatsNEW TO LAZO
-
Cafe Moka IslamoradaNEW TO LAZO
-
Café MokaNEW TO LAZO
-
Cakes by KarolNEW TO LAZO
-
CAO Bakery & CafeNEW TO LAZO
-
Caribbean CateringNEW TO LAZO
-
Catered Affairs of Key WestNEW TO LAZO
-
Croissants de France French BakeryNEW TO LAZO
-
Cupcake SushiNEW TO LAZO
-
Dennys Latin CafeNEW TO LAZO
-
Dulces by GleyNEW TO LAZO
-
elEVAte Pastry LabNEW TO LAZO
-
Elopement Florida KeysNEW TO LAZO
-
Floral Fantasy of the KeysNEW TO LAZO
-
Florida Keys Wedding CenterNEW TO LAZO
-
Flowers By J & JNEW TO LAZO
-
impeccably gourmet cateredNEW TO LAZO
-
Islamorada Brewery & Distillery (Islamorada)NEW TO LAZO
-
Island Girls ExcursionsNEW TO LAZO
-
Key Largo Conch HouseNEW TO LAZO
-
Key Largo FisheriesNEW TO LAZO
-
Key Largo Lighthouse Beach WeddingsNEW TO LAZO
-
Key West CakesNEW TO LAZO
-
Key West Catering CompanyNEW TO LAZO
-
Keys Chocolate and Ice CreamNEW TO LAZO
-
Keys Chocolates & Ice CreamNEW TO LAZO
-
Kylie’s CakesNEW TO LAZO
-
Mattheessen’s Candy KitchenNEW TO LAZO
-
Moondog Cafe Key WestNEW TO LAZO
-
Mrs. Mac's Kitchen (Little)NEW TO LAZO
-
Paris Coffee Gone CoastalNEW TO LAZO
-
Pastry MermaidNEW TO LAZO
-
Pierre's RestaurantNEW TO LAZO
-
Pinecrest Bakery - Key LargoNEW TO LAZO
-
Porky's Bayside Restaurant and MarinaNEW TO LAZO
-
Publix Super Market at MarathonNEW TO LAZO
-
Sandbar DonutsNEW TO LAZO
-
Small Chef At Large CateringNEW TO LAZO
-
Snook's Bayside Restaurant & Grand Tiki BarNEW TO LAZO
-
Stocking FactoryNEW TO LAZO
-
Sweet Savannah's of the Florida KeysNEW TO LAZO
-
The MarketplaceNEW TO LAZO
-
The Trading PostNEW TO LAZO
-
The Trading Post w/Key Lime Pie LadyNEW TO LAZO
-
Tropical Vibes Shave Ice Food TruckNEW TO LAZO
-
Vicky Bakery Key LargoNEW TO LAZO
-
Winn-DixieNEW TO LAZO
-
Winn-DixieNEW TO LAZO
Wedding Cakes & Desserts in nearby cities
Many wedding cakes & desserts travel. If Key West is short on dates, these cities are close enough to book.